Opposition ‘deliberately lying’ about Spy Law, Sheinbaum says: Wednesday’s mañanera recapped

At her Wednesday greeting property conference, a time aft the Senate approved authorities dubbed the “Spy Law,” President Claudia Sheinbaum rejected claims that information authorities volition beryllium capable to entree citizens’ idiosyncratic data, including connected their compartment phones, without archetypal obtaining a judicial warrant.

She besides declared that the national authorities “is not going to spy connected anyone.”

The president came prepared Wednesday greeting with a acquisition connected the Mexican Constitution aft nationalist headlines announced a caller “Spy Law” had passed successful the Senate. (Daniel Augusto/Cuartoscuro)

Her remarks came aft assorted politicians, non-government organizations and media outlets stated that information authorities volition beryllium capable to entree citizens’ idiosyncratic information without obtaining a tribunal order.

The National Action Party’s person successful the Senate, Senator Ricardo Anaya, asserted successful a societal media station connected Tuesday that the ruling Morena enactment “consolidated the #SpyGovernment: geolocation, entree to your health, slope and biometric information without a judge.”

The Network successful Defense of Digital Rights, a non-governmental organization, said connected societal media connected Tuesday that the Senate had granted the authorities “permission to spy.”

“Legalizing surveillance and entree to our [personal] accusation without controls, judicial orders oregon immoderate safeguard, done nationalist and backstage databases, is an maltreatment of quality rights,” the enactment said.

Sheinbaum denies immoderate intent of authorities to spy connected citizens 

During her Q&A league with reporters, Sheinbaum called for the beforehand leafage of the Wednesday variation of the Reforma paper to beryllium displayed connected a surface down her.

A header successful the paper referred to absorption parties’ informing that a “spy state” volition beryllium created arsenic the effect of the Mexican Congress’ support connected Tuesday of the National Investigation and Intelligence System Law.

“The absorption successful the Congress yesterday accused [the ruling party] Morena and its allies of imposing a ‘spy state,’ done laws that authorize information and instrumentality enforcement authorities to petition the geolocation of citizens without a tribunal order,” stated the opening condemnation of Reforma’s report.

“They besides questioned the authorization granted to authorities, successful the Investigation and Intelligence Law, to person entree to immoderate nationalist oregon backstage grounds with utile information to ‘create quality products,'” the study continued.

Senate grants Security Ministry wide information entree powers, sparking ‘police state’ fears

After speechmaking retired the report’s headline, Sheinbaum requested that Article 16 of the Mexican Constitution beryllium displayed, and reminded reporters that “no instrumentality tin interruption the Constitution.”

The president work retired 2 sections of Article 16, with which she sought to refute claims from absorption politicians and others that the authorities volition beryllium capable to entree people’s idiosyncratic information and way their determination without archetypal obtaining a tribunal order.

The sections she work retired — arsenic translated successful English-language copies of the Mexican Constitution disposable connected the websites of the Organization of American States and Mexico’s Electoral Tribunal — are arsenic follows:

“Private communications shall not beryllium breached. The instrumentality shall punish immoderate enactment against the liberty and privateness of specified communications, but erstwhile they are voluntarily fixed by 1 of the individuals progressive successful them. A justice shall measure the implications of specified communications, provided they incorporate accusation related to the perpetration of a crime. Communications that interruption confidentiality established by instrumentality shall not beryllium admitted successful immoderate case.”

“Only the national judicial authorization tin authorize telephone tapping and interception of backstage communications, astatine the petition of the due national authorization oregon the State Public Prosecution Service. The authorization that makes petition shall contiguous successful penning the ineligible causes for the request, describing therein the benignant of interception required, the individuals subjected to interception and the word thereof. The national judicial authorization cannot authorize telephone tapping nor interception of communications successful the pursuing cases: a) erstwhile the matters progressive are of electoral, fiscal, commercial, civil, labour oregon administrative nature, b) communications betwixt suspect and his attorney.”

“It’s what the laws say, it’s what the Criminal Code says,” Sheinbaum said.

“There tin lone beryllium an intervention, a GPS location, etcetera, nether tribunal order, unless it’s a missing person, a kidnapping, wherever the accusation is requested straight to the telephone institution successful bid to be successful an bonzer mode to a lawsuit of this type,” she said.

“… It’s false, it’s a prevarication that the laws approved [by the Senate connected Tuesday] person to bash with the authorities spying. False, they’re lying deliberately,” Sheinbaum added.

#Lamañanera | 📢 “Es falso, es mentira, el gobierno nary va a espiar a nadie como nos espiaron a nosotros”, afirmó la presidenta Claudia Sheinbaum (@Claudiashein) sobre la reforma de Telecomunicaciones. #MananeraDelPueblo #Mañanera pic.twitter.com/qwfBUcfNps

— OSCAR MARIO BETETA (@MarioBeteta) July 2, 2025

“The authorities is not going to spy connected anyone, similar they spied connected us,” she said, referring to alleged espionage carried retired by erstwhile governments, including the 2012-18 medication of erstwhile president Enrique Peña Nieto.

“In fact, I judge that each of america present were spied connected successful 1 mode oregon another, due to the fact that each of the colleagues person been members of the [Morena party] question for galore years,” said Sheinbaum, who was joined by assorted national and authorities officials astatine her greeting property conference.

“So we were each spied connected [but] we don’t spy connected anybody, nobody, perfectly nobody,” she said.

“What we privation is to physique a harmless country, successful peace,” Sheinbaum said.

In accordance with the constitution and Mexico’s laws, “a telephone involution tin lone beryllium approved by a judge,” she said.

“At nary clip is anyone being spied on. Let that beryllium clear,” Sheinbaum said.

By Mexico News Daily main unit writer Peter Davies ([email protected])