Marvel's Rise of Skywalker Adaptation Makes a Key Change Star Wars Fans Demanded

More than six years aft Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker deed theaters, Marvel Comics has yet completed its adaptation of the last Skywalker Saga movie. Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker Adaptation whitethorn beryllium precocious to the enactment (the bid was primitively solicited successful 2020 and canceled amid the COVID-19 pandemic), but it does question to bring thing caller to the table. The bid includes scenes and dialog not included successful the movie itself, and that includes a cardinal alteration fans person been begging for.

Read connected to larn what cardinal infinitesimal plays retired otherwise successful the last issue, and wherefore this alteration raises a fewer awkward questions successful its wake.

The Rise of Skywalker Adaptation's Biggest Change

Like The Rise of Skywalker novelization earlier it, Marvel's adaptation aims not conscionable to rehash the crippled of the film, but adhd caller scenes and lines of dialog that grow connected the plot. Issue #5 unsocial features respective cardinal changes. We really get to spot the connection Lando transmits to the postulation arsenic helium rallies an armada to combat the Sith Eternal fleet. We besides spot Rey and Ben Solo psychically speech to each different done the Force arsenic their Force dyad enslaved strengthens.

But the biggest alteration comes during the pivotal country wherever a battered but defiant Rey confronts her rejuvenated gramps Palpatine successful his Sith temple connected Exegol. In the movie, Rey is strengthened erstwhile she hears the voices of the galore dormant Jedi who came earlier her, from chap Skywalkers Anakin and Luke to Clone Wars-era giants similar Obi-Wan Kenobi, Luminara Unduli, and Mace Windu to the likes of Ahsoka Tano and Kanan Jarrus.

While that country proudly celebrates the enduring bequest of the Jedi, galore fans person been captious of the information that these cameos were simply voiceovers. We don't really spot these dormant Jedi manifest, contempt a changeable of Rey that intelligibly has country for an service of Force Ghosts successful the background. This is wherever the comic seeks to code that consciousness of disappointment. This time, Rey is physically joined by the Force Ghosts connected Exegol:

Art by Will Sliney. (Image Credit: Marvel/Lucasfilm)

This surely makes for a much cinematic moment. It's conscionable a shame the movie didn't spell this route, though nary uncertainty wrangling each these actors unneurotic for the involvement of a split-second radical changeable would person been a large undertaking.

This isn't adjacent the lone illustration of contented #5 inserting Force Ghosts into scenes wherever they don't beryllium successful the film. During the post-battle solemnisation connected Ajan Kloss, Luke and Leia materialize to look upon their friends with pridefulness and prosecute successful a spot of sibling banter.

Director J.J. Abrams was sadly constricted successful what helium could execute with Leia fixed the 2016 decease of Carrie Fisher. Both the novelization and the comic instrumentality vantage of the information that they don't look those aforesaid limitations, adding caller scenes and moments that question to grow Leia's relation successful the finale of the Sequel Trilogy.

The Mystery of Ahsoka Tano

As invited arsenic the Force Ghost country successful this contented is, it does rise immoderate awkward questions. For 1 thing, however are truthful galore of these Prequel-era Jedi capable to materialize astatine all? The franchise has established that the quality to look arsenic a Force Ghost isn't innate to Jedi, but the effect of aggravated grooming that Qui-Gon Jinn passed connected to Yoda and Obi-Wan aft his death. Why are truthful galore Prequel-era Jedi similar Mace, Luminara, Aayla Secura, and Ki-Adi-Mundi capable to manifest now? Is The Force bending the rules due to the fact that this is simply a peculiar occasion?

We're besides a small confused arsenic to the inconsistency of the ages depicted here. Why bash Anakin and Obi-Wan look successful their Clone Wars-era prime, but Luke is his aged, haggard hermit aforesaid from Ahch-To? When has Obi-Wan's Force Ghost ever manifested successful Ewan McGregor signifier alternatively than Alec Guinness form?

But the astir burning question present involves the beingness of Ahsoka Tano, a quality whose destiny during the Sequel Trilogy remains up successful the air. The Clone Wars and Rebels prima Ashley Eckstein recorded a enactment for Ahsoka successful the movie (this being good earlier Rosario Dawson was formed arsenic the live-action mentation of Ahsoka), but it was ne'er wide whether that was meant to connote Ahsoka is dormant by this point. Dave Filoni surely formed uncertainty connected the idea.

Should Ahsoka's inclusion successful this leafage beryllium taken arsenic a motion that she is so dead? Or is she simply Force projecting, arsenic Luke did during his last "battle" with Kylo Ren successful The Last Jedi? It whitethorn beryllium immoderate clip yet earlier Lucasfilm yet settles the issue. For now, Ahsoka's post-Return of the Jedi communicative is inactive precise overmuch a enactment successful progress. Dawson volition reprise her relation successful the upcoming 2nd play of Star Wars: Ahsoka, and she's besides expected to play a cardinal relation successful Filoni's live-action Star Wars movie.

What bash you deliberation of the changes made successful Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker Adaptation? Do they amended the story? Let america cognize successful the comments below. And beryllium definite to brushwood up connected each Star Wars movie and bid successful development.

Jesse is simply a mild-mannered unit writer for IGN. Allow him to lend a machete to your intelligence thicket by following @jschedeen connected BlueSky.